Guide
Why Your Payslip Might Be Wrong
Most payslip issues come from tax code changes, emergency tax, student loan setup, pension deductions, or pay-period timing differences.
Quick answer
If your net pay looks off, check the tax code, tax year, gross pay, pension line, and whether this is your first payslip from a new job.
On this page
Wrong tax code
A changed tax code can change PAYE even when your pay stays the same. The standard Personal Allowance is £12,570 in 2026/27, commonly reflected in 1257L. A code such as 1000L represents about £10,000 tax-free pay before period-table adjustments. A £2,570 annual allowance reduction would collect about £43 more a month at 20%, or £86 if the whole adjustment affects income taxed at 40%. These are annual-average illustrations, not exact payroll deductions.
L identifies the standard allowance category, but the number can include adjustments. BR taxes all affected taxable pay at 20%; D0 applies 40% in England and Northern Ireland, with C-prefixed equivalents in Wales. Scotland uses different S-prefixed codes. NT means no Income Tax is deducted from that source. Read the full code and basis, then compare with HMRC’s notice.
A different code can have a valid reason. Check:
- Previous employer submitted incorrect leaving information to HMRC.
- You have recently changed jobs and the new employer is using a temporary code.
- HMRC has adjusted the code for an underpayment from a prior year being collected over 12 months.
- A benefit in kind (company car, private medical insurance) has been added to the code, reducing the effective allowance.
Always read the tax code on every payslip. If it changes from one month to the next, find out why before assuming it is correct.
Has your payment changed?
Start with the difference between two payslips to find the relevant check.
See the lines on an example payslip
Explore a fictional payslip, follow its deductions and check how the gross and net figures fit together.
Emergency tax
W1, M1 or X indicates that PAYE uses the current period without looking back at earlier pay and tax; some software shows NONCUM. GOV.UK describes X for varying pay dates. 1257L M1 gives one month's allowance, not a full year's allowance.
That basis can overcollect or undercollect compared with the complete annual position, or give a similar result at steady pay. Give payroll your P45 and ask which starter details were used. A starter checklist is for before your first payment. After you have been paid, use Check your Income Tax to review your code and update your details. For a new job, follow up with HMRC if the code remains wrong after 35 days. See the emergency-tax examples and correction routes.
Check the likely cause next
If the issue looks tax-code related or you want to compare the payslip against HMRC-based estimates, use these next steps while you are still working through the numbers.
No P45 from previous employer
When you leave a job your employer must give you a P45, showing your pay and tax to date in the current tax year. Without it, payroll may not have your earlier pay and tax details. The starting code and basis depend on your starter information and any HMRC notice; a missing P45 does not always mean 1257L M1 or BR.
The BR code is designed for second jobs where you have already used your personal allowance elsewhere. It can also reflect other income or a temporary starter setup. Being your main job does not by itself prove BR is wrong; check where HMRC has allocated your allowance. At a gross salary of £30,000 per year, BR produces a monthly tax bill of roughly £500 compared with around £290 under 1257L if you qualify for the full standard allowance — a difference of £210 per month.
To fix this quickly:
- Track down your P45 from your previous employer (it should be provided at or shortly after your last day).
- Give it to the payroll team at your new employer as soon as possible.
- Before your first payment, use the starter checklist to give payroll missing details. After payment, ask payroll which starter information was used instead of completing a new checklist.
- After you have been paid, use Check your Income Tax to check the code and update any incorrect employment or income details.
Any overpaid tax due to a missing P45 is usually refunded automatically through later payslips once the correct cumulative code is applied.
Check the pay rules for your profession
Check the pay, hours and pension arrangements that apply to your particular role.
Student loan deductions starting
Student loan repayments are collected through PAYE alongside income tax and NI. HMRC notifies your employer which plan applies to you, and deductions start automatically — often without advance warning on your payslip.
The repayment thresholds and rates for 2026–27 are:
| Plan | Annual threshold | Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Plan 1 | £26,900 | 9% |
| Plan 2 | £29,385 | 9% |
| Plan 4 (Scotland) | £33,795 | 9% |
| Plan 5 | £25,000 | 9% |
| Postgraduate Loan | £21,000 | 6% |
Repayments are calculated on earnings above the threshold. On a Plan 2 loan at a salary of £35,000, the annualised monthly calculation is 9% of (£35,000 − £29,385) ÷ 12 = £42.1125. Payroll rounds the deduction down to a whole pound, giving £42 for steady monthly pay. If you have both an undergraduate and a postgraduate loan, both deductions can appear on the same payslip.
If a deduction appears unexpectedly, check the repayment plan in your Student Loans Company account or repayment correspondence. Ask payroll to check the plan and notice it used. Employers must follow the applicable starter, start-notice and stop-notice rules; contact the Student Loans Company if your repayment status is wrong.
Pension auto-enrolment
Employers assess eligible workers for automatic enrolment, normally from age 22 to State Pension age and above £10,000 annual earnings. For a usual qualifying-earnings scheme, total minimum funding is 8%, including at least 3% from the employer.
At £30,000 in 2026/27, qualifying earnings are £23,760. A 5% gross member contribution is £1,188 a year, or £99 monthly equivalent. Under relief at source the cash deduction is normally £79.20 and the provider adds £19.80. Under net pay, £99 is deducted before Income Tax. Salary sacrifice changes contractual salary and employer funding instead.
A valid opt-out within the statutory one-month window normally refunds contributions; later cessation and re-enrolment follow scheme and statutory rules. See workplace pensions.
Salary sacrifice changes
Salary sacrifice exchanges contractual cash salary for an employer benefit. The tax and NI result depends on the benefit and the rules: a pension contribution can reduce both, while a taxable benefit can offset some or all of the Income Tax saving. Use the benefits guide to check the arrangement rather than assuming every sacrifice saves both taxes.
Common salary sacrifice schemes include:
- Electric vehicle (EV) schemes — you sacrifice salary for a lease car. For a zero-emission car in 2026–27, the annual taxable benefit is generally 4% of its P11D value; Income Tax is then charged on that benefit at your applicable rate.
- Cycle-to-work — bike and safety equipment via salary sacrifice; higher-value packages depend on employer approval and appropriate consumer-credit arrangements; £1,000 is not a universal tax-exemption cap.
- Additional pension contributions — sacrificing salary into pension saves NI as well as income tax.
- Holiday purchase — some employers allow you to buy extra leave via sacrifice.
- Childcare (legacy schemes) — new sign-ups closed in October 2018, but existing members may still see deductions.
A new scheme may appear as a named line or as reduced gross cash pay. This reduces the gross pay figure used for tax and NI calculations, so PAYE and NI can fall, although taxable benefits and other adjustments may offset some of the saving — but the sacrifice amount is taken out first. If you did not expect the scheme to start this month, check with your HR team when the deductions were due to begin.
Pay-period timing differences
Net pay can look wrong not because of a tax or deduction error, but simply because of when payments fall within a pay period. Several timing effects regularly catch people out:
- Joining mid-month: £36,000 a year is £3,000 for a full ordinary month, but a start date alone does not establish the part-month amount. Ask which dates, contractual divisor and payroll cut-off were used. See the first-payslip checks.
- Back pay: if a pay rise was agreed late, the arrears for previous months may be paid as a lump sum in the current period. This pushes the gross figure up in one month, which can temporarily push you into a higher tax bracket on a non-cumulative code.
- Commission or bonus paid in arrears: a payment around 5/6 April needs its payment and entitlement dates checked. The work month alone does not establish the tax year. See the arrears and cross-year rules.
- Overtime in the next period: overtime worked in the last few days of a month may fall into next month's payroll cut-off, meaning it appears a month later than expected.
If the gross on your payslip is different from what you expected, clarify the payroll cut-off dates with your employer before concluding there is a tax error. Many apparent discrepancies dissolve once timing is accounted for.
Bonus and irregular payments
Bonuses and one-off payments are treated differently depending on whether your tax code operates on a cumulative or non-cumulative (W1/M1) basis.
Under a cumulative code, payroll calculates PAYE on taxable pay so far in the tax year, using the allowances and bands available up to that pay period and taking account of tax already deducted. A £5,000 bonus in month 9 is included in full when paid; the tax is not scheduled across the remaining months. Later cumulative calculations may adjust the overall position. See HMRC’s explanation of cumulative and non-cumulative codes.
Under a non-cumulative code (W1/M1), the payroll system has no memory of previous months. The bonus is simply added to this month's pay and taxed entirely at this month's rates. A £5,000 bonus on top of a £3,000 monthly salary pushes that month's gross to £8,000, which may tip you into the 40% band for that period alone. This produces a very large tax deduction in one month even though your annual earnings would not normally attract higher-rate tax.
A large irregular payment on a non-cumulative code can mean too much tax is collected, but a refund depends on your overall position and HMRC having the necessary income details. A later cumulative code may correct an overpayment through payroll. After the year ends, follow any tax calculation HMRC sends rather than assuming every M1/W1 code generates a refund.
SSP and SMP
Statutory payments replace your normal pay during periods of sickness or maternity leave, and their amounts are set by law rather than by your contract. If you receive statutory pay in a month where you expected your normal salary, the gross figure — and therefore all deductions — will look different.
Statutory Sick Pay (SSP) is paid from the first qualifying day of sickness. From 6 April 2026 it is the lower of £123.25 per week or 80% of average weekly earnings, for up to 28 weeks. The lower earnings limit and waiting days have been removed. SSP is subject to income tax and NI in the same way as normal pay. If your contractual sick pay is higher than SSP, your employer will pay the difference; if not, SSP is all you receive.
Statutory Maternity Pay (SMP) is paid for up to 39 weeks:
- First 6 weeks: 90% of your average weekly earnings with no cap.
- Remaining 33 weeks: the lower of £194.32 per week or 90% of your average weekly earnings.
Both figures are gross amounts — income tax and NI are still deducted. During paid maternity leave, employee pension contributions normally follow actual pay while employer contributions generally continue on the usual pre-leave basis; check the scheme and salary-sacrifice arrangements. The lower gross during SMP reduces your NI liability significantly, since NI has no cumulative mechanism and is simply applied to each pay period's earnings independently.
Attachment of earnings
Debt deductions can come from a court attachment of earnings order, council tax recovery, child maintenance or a DWP Direct Earnings Attachment. They are different arrangements: DWP does not need a court order for its attachment.
The amount may be fixed or calculated as a percentage. The earnings basis, protected amount, priorities and challenge route depend on the order and country. For example, DWP’s attachment normally protects 60% of the net earnings defined by its rules; that is not a universal limit for every debt deduction.
These deductions reduce the cash you receive without reducing taxable pay. Ask payroll for the issuing authority, reference, earnings calculation and any protected-earnings restriction. If the debt or amount is wrong, contact the court or authority named on the notice. Payroll must follow a valid instruction and cannot simply cancel it.
Write down the payslip facts first
Before you contact payroll, copy the facts from the payslip exactly as shown. Do not start with the net-pay difference alone. Payroll needs to know which input or deduction line you think is wrong.
| Field | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Pay period and pay date | PAYE and NI are calculated for a specific period, not just the month you noticed the problem. |
| Gross pay | This should match salary, overtime, bonus, commission, statutory pay, or hourly records. |
| Taxable pay | This can be lower than gross pay if pension or salary sacrifice is taken before tax. |
| NI-able pay | This can differ from taxable pay because NI has different rules from income tax. |
| Tax code and basis | BR, 0T, 1257L, K codes, W1, M1, or X can all change the PAYE result. |
| Year-to-date totals | Cumulative PAYE uses the tax-year history, so one payslip can only be checked properly with YTD figures. |
How to check each payslip line
- Match cash gross pay to your salary, hours and payroll cut-off.
- Identify salary sacrifice and the pension method. Do not subtract a sacrifice twice if gross pay is already reduced.
- Check taxable pay and NI-able pay separately. Payrolled benefits can increase taxable pay without adding cash; pension methods affect the two bases differently.
- Read the full tax code, including country and non-cumulative markers.
- Compare PAYE using the relevant period and any year-to-date adjustments.
- Check NI category and pay frequency; directors can have annual NI rules.
- Check loans and other cash deductions, including payroll rounding.
- Reconcile cash earnings plus cash additions such as reimbursements, less cash deductions, to the amount paid. Taxable pay alone is not a universal starting point for net cash.
- Compare year-to-date figures, allowing for a new tax year or employment record.
The checker provides an estimate from your inputs. Agreement cannot establish tax-code entitlement, every payroll adjustment or employer compliance. Ask payroll for the reconciliation when a difference remains.
What to send payroll
Keep the first message short and factual. A clear written record is more useful than a long explanation of everything that feels wrong.
Suggested format:
- Pay period and pay date.
- The line that looks wrong.
- The figure shown on the payslip.
- The figure you expected and why.
- Evidence attached: payslip, contract, timesheet, P45, HMRC tax-code notice, student-loan notice, or pension statement.
- The correction you are asking payroll to check.
Use neutral wording such as "please explain how this was calculated" or "please confirm whether this line should be corrected". Save stronger language for later if the evidence supports it.
Who to contact after payroll
If payroll cannot fix the issue, the next contact depends on the bucket.
| Issue | Likely next contact |
|---|---|
| Wrong tax code or old employment still showing | HMRC Personal Tax Account or income tax helpline |
| Student loan taken when records look wrong | Student Loans Company after payroll confirms the plan/notice used |
| Pension deducted but not visible in pension account | Pension provider first, then The Pensions Regulator if needed |
| Unpaid wages, wrong hourly rate, or contract dispute | Payroll/HR in writing; Acas in Great Britain or the Labour Relations Agency in Northern Ireland if unresolved |
| PAYE calculation does not match the code and taxable pay | Payroll first; HMRC if payroll says it is following an HMRC code |
Do not share full payslips publicly. Redact your National Insurance number, payroll number, address, employer details, bank details, and any other personal identifiers.
Your legal rights
Employees and workers generally have a right to an itemised payslip on or before payday. There are exceptions, including some armed-forces, police and seafaring roles; see GOV.UK's payslip guidance.
Payslips must show earnings before and after deductions and variable deductions. Fixed deductions may be explained separately as allowed by the rules. Hours must be shown where pay varies by time worked.
Raise unexplained pay or deductions with payroll in writing and keep your payslips, contract and hours records. If unresolved, contact ACAS for Great Britain, or the Labour Relations Agency in Northern Ireland. Tribunal procedures, remedies and time limits depend on the claim and jurisdiction; seek guidance promptly.
What to do next
- Compare your gross pay with your contract or hours worked.
- Check the tax code on the payslip and whether it shows W1, M1, or X.
- Check if pension, student loan, or salary sacrifice has started this month.
- Run the payslip checker with the figures from the payslip.
- If the tax code looks wrong, compare it with HMRC messages and your personal tax account.
- If it is a first payslip after changing jobs, keep an eye on the next payslip too.
Try the tool
Check your payslip or model a change.
Use the checker if you already have a payslip. Use the calculator if you want to model take-home pay or salary-sacrifice changes before payday.
About this guide
Written by Dan. Dan has spent 20 years working across payroll, HR, benefits and reward. IsMyPayRight is an independent personal project, not connected with any employer or with HMRC.
AI tools help with research and drafting. The official sources used are listed at the end of the guide.
This is general guidance, not a professional review of your circumstances. Read our editorial process and the corrections log.
Methodology and sources
See how the calculations work, which sources they use, how results are tested, and which payroll details the estimates cannot verify.
Common questions
- Why does my payslip look wrong when my salary has not changed?
- The most common reasons are a changed tax code, emergency-tax treatment, student-loan deductions starting, pension changes, or a timing difference in the payroll period rather than a true salary change.
- Should my employer fix a wrong payslip or should I contact HMRC?
- Ask payroll to fix gross pay, pension, or deduction-line errors. Contact HMRC when the issue is the tax code or PAYE basis because employers normally have to apply the code HMRC has issued.
- Can a payslip be wrong for one month and correct itself later?
- Yes. Temporary tax-code issues, starter information gaps, and cumulative PAYE adjustments can make one payslip look wrong and then unwind on later payslips once payroll has the right data.
- What should I check before telling payroll my payslip is wrong?
- Record the pay period, gross pay, taxable pay, NI-able pay, tax code, NI category, pension line, student-loan plan, net pay, and year-to-date totals. Payroll can usually investigate faster when you point to a specific line.
- Should I contact payroll, HMRC, SLC, or my pension provider?
- Start with payroll for payslip calculation or gross-pay issues. Contact HMRC for tax-code records, SLC for student-loan records, and the pension provider if deductions were taken but do not appear in your pension account.
- Should I call a payroll error fraud?
- Not at first. Keep the first message factual and ask for the calculation or remittance to be explained. Escalate only when you have evidence of the specific issue and the right route for that issue.
- Is it wrong if no tax was taken on my payslip?
- Not necessarily. On a normal cumulative code, payroll looks at your pay and tax since 6 April, so no tax is due if your taxable pay so far is within the tax-free pay built up to date. A corrected code can also refund earlier tax instead. No employee NI is due on pay up to £1,048 a month (£242 a week).
- How can I check the tax and National Insurance on my payslip are right?
- For most employees (NI category A), NI is 8% of NI-able pay between £1,048 and £4,189 in the month (£242 to £967 weekly), plus 2% above that, using that pay period alone. Income Tax is harder to check by hand because it depends on your full tax code and year-to-date pay and tax.
Official sources
Use these references to check the rules behind this guide. Check the tax year and your circumstances before applying an example to your own pay.
- Starter checklist: before and after first pay
HMRC
- P800 refund instructions
HMRC
- Tax code meanings
HMRC
- 2026/27 employer rates and thresholds
HMRC
- Student-loan payroll rounding rules
HMRC
- Workplace pension contributions
HMRC
- Payslip rights and exceptions
HMRC
- Debt repayments taken from wages
GOV.UK
- Direct Earnings Attachments: employer guidance
DWP
- Pension contributions missing from your pension
TPR
- Payslips and resolving problems
ACAS
- Pay deductions and resolving disputes in Northern Ireland
nidirect

